if you dont understand, Fireproof Games told us that The Witch has appeared before her assumed first appearance, The Room VR: A Dark Matter, so it's assumed that The Witch was one of the other female characters

the only known female characters were Margaret Cox (first appearance The Room Two), Abigail Lockwood (first appearance The Room 4: Old Sins) and Lucy (first appearance The Room Two)

Lucy has a low chance of being The Witch, as she's only mentioned in letters and Montfaucon's notepad and she makes no appearance, no pictures of her or anything, just her name being written

Abigail made appearances on the newspaper and a self portrait on the floor in the Foyer of Waldegrave Manor, and a scene where she and Edward haves an argument and it's animated

Maggy made an appearance in the newspaper too

and read the post above

and

yeah