i figured out how BF and GF got killed in Mario’s Madness and I’m disappointed in myself why it took me this long

In the first cutscene, Horror Mario says 3 songs, only 3

then it goes on

It’s-A-Me (First song)

Starman Slaughter (Second song)

but then they go through ALLLLL the other songs

and THEN arrive back at Horror Mario for the final (All-Stars)

so yeah

they broke the rules