Uh I was originally only gonna do this after finishing the first 3 seasons of II but Episode 14 of Season 2 was legit so good I decided to do it early

Don't spoil Season 3/4 plz

Hosts/Non-contestants

MePhone 4 - ???

Steve Cobs - @gamejolt (THE JOLT MAN)

Season 1

Apple - @IHasAFaceLULZ24 (His pink-fox OC is dumber in canon, also he asked to be Apple)

Balloon - ???

Baseball - ???

Bomb - ???

Bookcasey - ???

Bow - ???

Knife - ???

Lightbulb - @freddrick_fazbear (Do I need to say anything)

Marshmellow - ???

Nickel - @Beopzowl (He was Nickel in the BFDI rp)

OJ - ???

Paintbrush - Me (This has nothing to do with the whole Paintbrushes gender thing I'm not even LGBT, I'm just friends with Nightmare)

Paper - ???

Pepper - ???

Pickle - ???

Salt - ???

Taco - ???

Season 2

Box - ???

Cheesy - ???

Cherries - ??? and ???

Dough - ???

Fan - @SirCrimson22067

Microphone - ???

Soap - ???

Suitcase - ???

Test Tube - @deadjxiden

Tissues - ???

Trophy - ???

Yin-Yang - ??? and ???

(I'll do more tommorow school sucks)