we wont count the bottom one becouse i dont know those characters

in the better as a skin tier we have

slenderman ( creepypasta )

the rake ( creepypasta/urban legends)

nightmare ( fnaf )

W.D gaster ( undertale )

mr.frog ( smiling friends )

for slenderman i think he would be a great skin for the fogborn ( or man from the fog if you know what this character is based on wich is the man from the fog from the famous minecraft horror mod ) that is becouse theyre both tall and often are seen in foggy spots ( even tough its never foggy in the original minecraft mod ) but you know what i mean

for the rake it would be the fogborn again becouse there is no current character in the game that shares the same proportions

for nightmare from fnaf it would probably be springtrap becouse not only are they from the same franchise but making springtrap have a black colorscheme is something really like to give springtrap sometimes and making him see through would be good too since it would also show the corpse inside to let you see that there is a dead guy in that suit coming to get ya

for W.D gaster i am unsure wich character to give to him so ill make a fan assumption and guess that pillar chase will add chara in a future update becouse she seems as a way better undertale character to put in the game becouse yknow they actually are a murderer or monster that is bloodlusted

for mr.frog i would give him to pinkie becouse they have the same build and theyre both pretty goofy looking

now for the bad idea section oooohhhh im gonna piss people off but i will try to give a good reason why they would be bad additions

first one are cartoon cat and god of roadkill wich are creatures made by legendary horror artist trevor henderson yade yade he makes monsters that make no sense yade yade go play the vs cartoon cat fnf mod if you want a basic synopsis of what trevor henderson is becouse i am not gonna sit here and explain everything

nr 1 is cartoon cat

cartoon cat has good potential but what the problem is with trevor henderson is that his fans usually think that everything fanmade is just slop and most of them are right becouse most youtubers are just milking his creatures to make kids content but the gmod models are good wich they disagree with becouse most of them are innacurate to how they look in the art ( and to say theyre made in scource engine so they had to do with what they could ) sorry for this brief nerding out now lets go back to why cartoon cat cant get added apart from him being a fan favorite trevor henderson monster and that his fans gatekeep this thing as if its mickey mouse and theyre disney is becouse i dont think he would be a good addition like most of these character in pillar chase are videogame characters ofcourse there are exceptions becouse there are also various analog horror/arg characters but theyre just trying to let you see that there are corrupted videogame characters breaching into roblox and chasing you down until you die of cringe

same for the god of roadkill but here only the fanbase gate keeping him is at stake ( same for bridge worm )

six from little nightmares is way too big to fit on maps ( the big problem will be an issue for most characters in this tier ) as well as not having a move set that actually fits within pillarchase

huggy wuggy is there becouse he is a controversial character ( mostly becouse of kids ) and becouse nobody probably wants to see huggy wuggy

the zoochosis girraffe doesnt have a noteworthy moveset and it also suffers from being too big to fit on maps

ban ban from garten of banban ( everyone knows why this is a bad idea )

jayson voorhees is a bad choice becouse people from forsaken would probably try to beef with pillarchase for stealing their characters

leather face michael myers and john kramer are here becouse i also dont like movie killers in pillarchase ( and becouse of the companies scowering any corner of the internet to see if someone put their characters in a videogame about chasing thats not dead by daylight and then taking it down )

so many fucking dinosaurs from jurrasic park i cant even fucking count how many ( like seriously these dino's take up most of this entire tierlist and i put all of them in bad due to either their size or limited moveset as well as me not wanting movie villians in pillerchase cuz i think movie characters dont belong there very well )

then jaws from the famous movie jaws

like buddy do you fucking look at the size of this shark and see it be able to move freely on a pillarchase map? no you dont hes too fucking big ( yes i know jaws is a megalodon but cmon man its a goddamn shark that ate a giant mushroom from mario )

then we have bill cipher ( god what am i gonna piss people off with this decision )

bill cipher is as you know a fictionally busted character like goku

so in order to make him fair the devs have to either nerf bill and make the gravity falls fans mad becouse they cant powertrip

or make him have his powers and make every pillar chase player mad

oh and then we have coldsteel fuck that guy like who wants coldsteel? he sucks more then sunky ( in my opinion ) and he isnt even horror themed hes just a shitty sonic oc

then we have the tier where i say these have not enough moveset potential ( these are characters that either dont do much in their respective franchise or just do nothing )

first we have negative mickey from the abandoned by disney creepypaste or how many people know where he is from fnati or five nights at treasure island

his nr 1 weakpoint is that he does not do much in the creepypasta or in the fnaf fangame he just stays there being all menacing and looking like mickey mouse so not much combat goin on

nr 2 being is that disney is a scary exe that will take down pillarchase if mickey even shows a finger

then we have the woodcrawler from the gemini entertainment analog horror tbh idk why i didnt put this thing in the i dont know wtf this is tier but i saw glimpses of it and its not really a pillarchase like character its just a giant centipede made out of wood wich is nothing much to go off of

then we have another one that might piss you off that being phen-228 or the boiled one made by doctor nowhere

nr 1 is that he is way too big to fit on the map

nr 2 being is that he does not do much in the one episode he came from ( combat wise ) like he only manipulates you and tries to take over your mind wich doesnt really lower someones health it just gives them eternal sleep paralasys

now we have boisvert from that one analog horror that scared the shit out of me becouse i dont like it when creatures just run at me like boisvert did i hate how he moved and fuck him for doing that

oh and he did nothing battle like in the series

then we have freddy fazbear from fnaf i dont think he would be a great addition to the roster as a playable character but i think he would be great for something else wich is an alternate springtrap killing cutscene where freddy would bite the player in half like he did to max in the movie

wich is springtraps endo summoning from dead by daylight except freddy and he bites you

for both the foxy bonnie chica and freddy skin as well as his original state he would summon freddy on how he looks in the games

for his spiffy skin he would summon a golden with black version of freddy

for his nightmare skin ( wich is the one i made up a phew seconds ago ) he would summon nightmare freddy

for his blank skin he would summon a blank freddy

rgb skin has rbg freddy gnorpy has gnorpy freddy

but blackheart freddy uses blackheart bonnie to do it ( becouse blackheart springtrap skin is based on the blackheart bonnie from fnaf ar )

his yellow rabbit skin would summon a freddy that looks like its from the movie

the burntrap skin would summon a malfunctioning glamrock freddy and then proceed to stuff the player in the chest cavity gregory jumps into in sb then glamrock freddy proceeding to crush the player

ignited springtrap would just use ignited freddy

the clown springtrap skin ( from fnaf ar ) would summon a magician freddy

grinch one would summon a freddy dressed up as an elf

idk about the baldi one tho

for his pixelated skin he would summon pixelated fredbear and then proceed to do the bite of 87 on the player

his twilight form wich is salvage from a random fnaf fangame and not the hoax one so idk about this one if it was the hoax one i would probably think he would have used withered freddy to do it

and i also dont know about easter bunny skin

now we have pyramid head from silent hill ( i dont think he has that much creative things to get from him )

monster from fnf

( this guy never fought even once in the game so even tough i like fnf i dont think he would make a good addition to pillarchase )

then we have the guy from buckshot roullette

its just a guy with a gun

then we have bigfoot ( this is the first folklore character i would put a bit on top becouse every mass collab game needs a character that is basically an oversized monkey ( like donkey kong in super smash bros ) for the rest idk becouse he never really fights

now we go to pointless tier

nr 1 is the peanut scp aka scp-137

he just cant move until you look away like the players could just stare you down and they would instantly win

the mandela catalogue people

like what do they do mimic other players after they killed them? and then doing a terrible job at mimicing them?

the wario apparation

he is simply too big and is mostly not creepy in the slightest

then we have suicide squidward

its fucking squidward

red from the nes godzilla creepypasta

hes simply too big

ben drowned

same problem with scp-137 but even when you are looking away they cant really move

ennard from fnaf

sorry buddy but we have a better fnaf protagonist on our hands

now in the idk maybe tier we have

missingno he is a maybe becouse we still have no pokemon creepypasta characters yet

the problem is i dont know what kind of moveset he would have like maybe a kabutops slash and glitching the screen out so the player cant see very well

tails doll is a maybe due to him not being very creepy and becouse we already have a fuckton of sonic horror characters but if tails doll would be in he would have probably been a guy who would float around tamper with lighting and just grab the player or using that weird energy crystal thing on his head ( my theory is that its a shard of the shattered master emeralds )

bon from the walten files

we already have springtrap so his conclusion would probably be worthless ( i should have put bon in the skins tier becouse he would be way better as a skin for springtrap )

zardy from zardy's maze or the fnf zardy mod

i dont really know him that well so well skip this one

the xenomorph and predator shouldve been lower becouse theyre both movie villains and i dont want those in pillarchase no matter if i like them or not soooo yeah

in the would be neat section

we have the locust from doctor nowhere

they can be here becouse they actually show more combat then the boiled one but a lil less then to be considered for this tier like it should have been in the maybe tier

the scp that can make it through is scp-049 aka the plague doctor he is a doctor wich are always scary and this one experiments on immortality to make undead slaves so if he kills a player he will turn it into an npc zombie minion wich is almost as fast as the player but will disintegrate after a while due to the plague doctors medicine not being strong enough in return for that the plague doctor is pretty slow and get only faster with an ability that charges quicker then anything else in his arsenal that enhances speed by 5 wich basically makes him as fast as a zombie minion for 16 seconds he does this by brewing a speed potion or smth

then we have fake peppino from pizza tower

he has a lot of potential especially in pillar chase due to his weirdness and adventual creepyness

then we go to pretty good idea wich has only one entry that being the man in the suit or how most people call it springtrap if he was the godzilla actor ( the joke was not as disrespect for the creator and i respect his descision to cancel the goji tapes series becouse of the fans being mean to him )

he would basically spit blood and do other goji stuff except hes a man in a suit now

and then we have the has amazing potential tier

wich includes herobrine

like for the man from the fog to be included in pillarchase was pretty surprising so maybe they could add another minecraft horror icon and they might as well choose the biggest one like who doesnt know herobrine?

he would probably be a fusion on how he acts in the creepypasta ( wich is being a stalking figure in the fog )

and then being one of his fan interpertations of him wich is him being a neusance and killing everyone

( his final kill would be him teleporting the player to the void and then stabbing your player in the heart with a diamond sword and then pushing you into a hole in the wall wich is a refference to one of his symptoms wich is his 3 by 3 holes in the wall then he stuff a bunch of tnt in it then proceeds to cover up the hole and then blowing the tnt up )

and for monika

well she would put just monika pop ups all over your screen she has an enraged mode ( wich is a refference to her did i scare you jumpscare wich increases her attack and speed for a short while ) she can throw a pen that can stab the player ( in her yuri skin she throws a knife ) and in her final kill she touches the code and deleted you like she deleted the other characters in ddlc

and thats it really