Johnathan is an old character I made in reference to a random joke from one of Ryon's Streams about Friedrich's real name being Johnathan. Anyway, I was listening to Finger Lakes and thought to myself "hmm... what if Five Nights at Johnathan's was a thing that existed?" so I decided to make the rest of the cast.

From right to left their names are:

-Mr Famished

-EBT-000

-Johnathan

-Claramari

-Ben the Butcher

Random trivia you didn't ask for:

-EBT is an acronym for "Electronic Bar Tender"

-Ben the Butcher is a painfully unsubtle reference to The Gaslight District

-Claramari is heavily based on a character from a really old fangame I made