Flumpty in a nutshell:

Who is this? (wrong answers only)

ONAF Posters.

Into the Water

Who is this? (wrong answers only)

FIND ME .... MICHAEL!!!!

Who is this? (wrong answers only)

Who is this? (wrong answers only)

Suggested by @Frozen_Dark_Oswald , I hope you like it!!

Who is this? (wrong answers only)