I've been drawing some new sprites, and... Which one's better?

So I foud these pictures while getting my backup...

New icon! The old one looked kind of silly :/

New header!

Check the post above!

Possible new icon

New thumbnail!!! (that's very important)

What happened to the lantern?

New (left) VS Old (Right). Not implemented yet, I want your opinions.

I actually realized how unnatural and straight up wrong the previous sprite looked, so I'm remaking it. The walking animation has been the greatest challenge so far.