Plot

Cold open

The episode starts with Blocky doing a podcast, or as he calls it, blockcast, with Flower. Flower comments on how bad the name is, making Blocky demand that she get out. Blocky then summons Gelatin, who questions his desperate attempts to air another show. Blocky responds that Blocky's Funny Doings International is on hiatus due to all the perjury stuff, so he's trying to get a new show greenlit. Gelatin comments on how a podcast sounds lame, so Blocky tells him to leave and calls Flower back. Blocky asks Flower how she is, and she expresses her concerns about the voting and how she's stressed out about it but trails off as she realizes Blocky hadn't been listening. Blocky tells her that she had been pranked and that it was a pranking podcast. Flower is unamused by this. Walking over to Woody, Blocky tells him that Flower was right and that his idea sucked. Then, from behind a bush, Purple Face calls the Have Nots for Cake at Stake.

Cake at Stake

As the Have Nots arrive beneath the bush, Purple Face welcomes them. Blocky speaks up, asking if Purple Face had permission to host the Cake at Stake, to which the latter reluctantly responds that he did. Blocky doesn't buy it and leaves. He's then replaced by a stick.

To set the mood, Purple Face sings his own Cake at Stake theme, only to be interrupted by Flower and Firey, angering him. Controlling his rage, he starts his song over again but is interrupted yet again by none other than Four, prompting him to get on with the votes.

He deems Firey safe with 17,899 votes. Firey complains about how they haven't been getting any cakes lately, and Purple Face begrudgingly comes up with a prize on the spot, a member of the Have Cots each. Firey gets Teardrop, who scuttles off without acknowledging him.

Woody is also deemed safe with 17,054 votes. He gets Lollipop, who confusedly asks where they are.

Out of the final two, Flower and stick (Blocky), Purple Face mistakenly says that Flower is eliminated. She gives a long speech about her aspiration to redeem herself, and how she still came up short. Realizing his mistake, Purple Face corrects himself and tells Flower that she's safe with 11,547 votes, and stick is eliminated. She dances in celebration, only to stop as Purple Face gives her Leafy as a prize, grumbling about how he had ruined her moment. Blocky returns surprised that the others were still in the bush. Flower informs him that he's been eliminated, much to his dismay. Woody runs over to Blocky and picks him up, upset at his friend's elimination. Blocky reassures him that things would be alright, telling him to pull some pranks while he was gone. Blocky then interrupts himself, recalling the times Woody had pulled pranks in episodes prior. This allows Blocky to realize that if anyone was worthy enough to be the star of his show, it was Woody.

Before the challenge

Four told the Have Nots to get out of the bush, which Teardrop reveals by throwing Gelatin into it. Blocky then tells Four that he's eliminated, and asks him to be sent to the Big Rotating Building. His last words were to make Woody proud of him. Four was angry that Purple Face did Cake at Stake instead of him, and decides to despawn Purple Face. X then told everyone that they will be battling for immunity and there would be no more teams. Four was angry that they took all the big moments, which Purple Face laughs at, so Four despawns him again. Four said that since they took all the big moments, he decided to be selfish and announces a challenge to make the best party for him. Purple Face decides to start the intro, but since he has no hands, he tells Flower to get behind him and raise her hand, to make it look like Purple Face started the intro.

The challenge

Gelatin asked Lollipop and Firey if they had seen Teardrop since she had become violent lately. Lollipop then responds by saying she had not seen Teardrop. Firey then asks what party will Lollipop makes, which she responds by making a terrible one. Gelatin then decided to plan a party for Four with cheesecake, forks, and musical chairs (which is the basis for Teardrop's "I'm Sorry Gelatin" party). Lollipop then doubts his plan. Gelatin changes his plan to make a party for X instead, using baskets. Gelatin then decided to talk to Teardrop about how she drew him getting killed (from "Who Stole Donut's Diary?"), actually killing him by using the shears (from "Fashion For Your Face!") and threw him into the bush, and tells her to leave him alone. Teardrop then walks away in sadness.

Leafy greets Firey, only for Lollipop to interrupt her. Flower then asks Leafy to hang out with her. Leafy then decided to talk to Firey about ignoring her. Lollipop then asks Woody (which is fulfilling the role left by Blocky after his elimination) to give him the worst possible music. Woody then gets Purple Face, to Lollipop's pleasure. Leafy then asks Flower how far is her store. To get there, they sink themselves into quicksand, dropped 1000 feet, and cross the 50-mile tightrope. Meanwhile, Woody then designs the "Happy Halloween" banner for Lollipop's party. Gelatin then tells Firey, who made a gift, that he is done with his X-themed party. Flower then finally comes to the shop, which Leafy expected was a megastore, but it turned out to be a stand instead. Rusty Coin gave them all the party supplies, but after Flower had four boxes of party supplies, she decided to run away with Leafy, while Rusty Coin follows.

Lollipop tells Purple Face about how the song is going, to which he replied that he is still rehearsing his song. Lollipop, knowing how rude Purple Face is, admires him, saying that it is perfect for this party. Leafy and Flower then ran to their own wall and floor to throw the party supplies to the wall, making them automatically attach. Four proceeds to see the parties the contestants set up, starting with Gelatin, Gelatin then tells Four that he made a party for X. Four gives his own party 0/10 because the parties were supposed to be for him alone. Firey then presents his party, which is a Ferris wheel, like the one in the first season, but it alternates between water and lava so that he and Leafy would both enjoy. Leafy then praises him for the gift. Firey then apologized for pushing Leafy away. Four gives this Ferris wheel 2/10 because despite the Ferris wheel being a cool idea, the Ferris wheel had nothing to do with him. He then proceeds to ask Leafy what party did she make, only for Leafy to answer that she just helped Flower make her party and did not have time to make one herself, referring to Four as "Your Fournor" Four then gave her 0/10 for her party. Four then says 3 parties were made so far, none of them with him in it, which only made him upset.

Four then tells Woody to present his party. Four then translates Woody’s words, and Woody presents his party, which was themed on Purple Face’s instead. It was revealed to be a prank by Woody, who wanted to make Blocky proud. Four gave Purple Face's party which Woody because he found Purple Face funny, a 1/10 score. Flower, after being told by Four to show her party, shows the decorations on the wall, which were made by throwing the party supplies into the wall. Four asks how does Flower's merchandise repel vomit, and gives her party a 5/10. Four decides to go to Teardrop's party, only to find out that it was not meant for him, instead of being an "I'm Sorry Gelatin" party with musical chairs, cheesecake, and forks, the same party which was thought by Gelatin himself. Teardrop decides to present Gelatin a comic book, entitled "Gelatin's Space Walk". Gelatin praises Teardrop for apologizing to him, but Four tells them to make a party based on him instead of using them to fix their personal conflict, giving them a 1/10 rating for Teardrop. Lollipop then presents her party to Four, which was a terribly-made Halloween-themed party (which is the wrong time of the year to celebrate it), which was also made with spoons, of which she showed disgust towards earlier. It also has Purple Face sing terribly. Four said that Lollipop was the worse performer, only to say it that ironically, Lollipop's terribly-made party was the best at 10/10 since he loved Halloween and he liked the song. The immunities were given to Lollipop and Flower, with the former having the option to give immunity to one more person, of which she chose Gelatin. Which brings Firey, Woody, Leafy, and Teardrop up for elimination.

Stinger

While spun at the Big Rotating Building, Blocky receives a notification regarding a new video Woody published. Blocky announces to everyone at the BRB that a new video of Woody's Funny Doings International came out. In the video, Woody represents a prank: detaching the Ferris wheel Firey and Leafy were riding. Blocky praised the video, calling it "pretty legit".