considering puzzles had a Rough childhood i don’t think his birthdays were treated like birthdays by his father… or anyone around him really, only a few “happy birthdays” and nothing else . the closest puzzles would get to a proper birthday would be getting a bag of treats, and that’d only be when his fathers in a good mood…

this would probably lead to puzzles not celebrating his birthday that often when he’s older . either he’s too caught up in his desperation for fame or he just . Doesn’t wanna . Sure, it gives him ATTENTION for that day, but still . Might not wanna be reminded of his childhood . Lol

sorry i was eating and ice cream cake since it was my sisters birthday and this appeared in my head like a prophetic vision