16 days ago

small rant about the state of Treasure Island 3D Quadrilogy

(read article)


Before I begin with the rant, I need to make it clear that this is in no way meant to shit on MrKlol or his game. It's his game and he can do what he wants with it. I am just simply sharing my opinions on the recent changes he has made. DO NOT TRY TO PRESSURE HIM TO CHANGE ANYTHING BACK.

Ok

  1. The New Models.

    image.png

P.N. Mickey actually looks nice. Oswald's model, on the other hand, needs some improvement.

The new models don't really feel like mickey and oswald if you get what I'm saying. I completely understand that he wanted to use original models and that is great, but he should try to make the models look as accurate to the original characters as possible.

Also, I'm sorry but...

image.png

this looks pretty mid

2. Suicide Mouse's replacement

(this isn't what the character's model is gonna be, this is just where its from)

image.png

Once again, being original is great. I love how he took the time to do something different but...

why is a kirby character in a fnati game?

This is something that belongs in stuck at the bunker.

And I know that this will most likely not be canon, but still, it does not fit.

3. Photo's model

for those who are unaware, Photo's (this game's version of PNM) model is directly based on someone else's concept art

image.png
image.png

An old render of Photo even directly copies PNM's pose in the original art

Now I'm sure MrKlol has credited the original artist, but that doesn't excuse how the his version is literally the same design only 3D (This is especially apparent in the new model) The exact same thing applies to Photo's design in the 2D version of the game.

Note: After typing this, I learned that Belial's design is also directly taken from art by the same artist

I'm not saying taking inspiration is a bad thing, not at all, but there's a fine line between being inspired by something and just straight up copying it.

4. The state of Treasure Island 2D Quadrilogy

We haven't gotten an update on the 2D version in 5 MONTHS. I understand that MrKlol may want to shift all focus towards the 3D version, but it's still sad to see an equally great game get choked out by the other one.

A message to MrKlol (if he even sees this)

I had no ill intentions while writing this. I simply wanted to make my thoughts about your game known. I hope you can take these criticisms in mind and use them to help make your game the best it can be. End of message.



1 comment

Loading...

Next up

Thank you for 10 followers and (over) 100 views!

LETS FUCKING GOOOOO!!!!!!!!! 100!!!

HELP WANTED WITH INDIE GAME

(read article)

100 Followers (Read Article)

"go back eating peoples necks blood"

get a load of this cornball

@Chiro_The_Skunk listen man I've sided with you for pretty much this whole drama but please for the love of god don't fucking raid my friend's server OR spam on his posts. You're only giving him and his supporters more reasons to hate you.

we've been cursed with knowing this meme exists.

Coming Soon... (repost)

cabe try not to start working on a new project without finishing the first one challenge (IMPOSSIBLE)