Hello. I think I found the reason behind why the game automatically loaded into Night 5. If you had the original Five Nights at Maggie's 1's save file which had Night 5 in it, that same save file will also apply to the remake. Meaning, if you got to Night 5 in Five Nights at Maggie's (2016), you ALSO got to Night 5 in Five Nights at Maggie's (2021). Now, why is this the case? I have a guess... You know the %appdata% thing that you use to cheat save files to skip a night? (Don't be oblivious, we all did it at one point.) If you downloaded FNaM 1 classic and remake and then go to MMFApplications, you'd notice there's no separate file for FNaM 1 remake. But when you modify the save file that simply says "Maggies" (referring to FNaM 1), you'd notice the saves for both games were changed to. I think it's because the save files have the same name.