Help needed again Sob

which lighting is better?

#GJAsks "Gaming Alien" is pretty vague, but thats good because then this guy might count:

EMPEROR XIZZLE (from Sims 2: Strangetown [on the Nintendo 3DS])

𝒥𝒪ℒℒ𝒴 HOLLY TIMEEEEEE

WOOHOOOOOOOOO

#JOLTMAS #MAGMAS #CHRISTMAS #JOLLY #art #ITSTHE25THBABYYYYYY #December25th #HappyHolidays #MerryChristmas

#AHollyJollyChristmasToYou()

𝒥𝒪ℒℒ𝒴 /ref (if ykyk, (@Duuud ) )

JUPO

which one is better? (please help me I've been going back and forth on it way too much aughhh...... pretty please!!!<3)

Underfell sans battle concepts

1st image: the reference image I used for what holly looks like.(from google images)

2nd image: my (from-scratch) drawing BEFORE any shading/lighting/details.

The rest of them are all in the order that I took the screenshots, and that I did those parts.

bro I'm cooked/cooking, how??????

how is it already at 5 reads Sob

scrapped UI

help....