Trophies
That Wasn't So Bad, Right?
Complete the first night.
Stare Master
Complete the second night.
Did You Say Bugbear!?
Complete the third night.
Party of None
Complete the fourth night.
Five Nights in Equestria
Complete the fifth night.
Mane Six
Complete the sixth night.
Friendship is Magic - Part 1
Beat Ponyville preset in custom night without invincibility.
Friendship is Magic - Part 2
Beat Magic of Friendship preset in custom night without invincibility.
Prize Possession
Beat Party Cannon preset in custom night without invincibility.
Pinkamena Diane Pie
Beat Cupcakes preset in custom night without invincibility.
Monster-hunting Agency
Beat Stranger Than Fan Fiction preset in custom night without invincibility.
Uh...
Beat Stranger Than Fan Fiction 2 preset in custom night without invincibility.
Jackie Chun
Beat The Turtle Hermit Way preset in custom night without invincibility.
This Is Our Big Night
Beat Our Big Night preset in custom night without invincibility.
The Return of Harmony
Beat Stable 1 preset in custom night without invincibility.
Discordant Harmony
Beat Stable 2 preset in custom night without invincibility.
Mane-iac
Beat any custom night preset with Color Mode, Smooze, and Long Nights enabled without invincibility.
Shadow Play
Beat the secret Pony of Shadows night.
How to Befriend a Pony of Shadows
Beat the secret Pony of Shadows night without running out of flashlight power.
7/20
Beat Chaosville preset in custom night without invincibility.
Nightmare Night
Beat Nightmare Moon preset in custom night without invincibility.
Hope Hollow
Beat Ponyville preset in custom night with Shadow Mode enabled and without invincibility.
Shadow of a Doubt
Beat Magic of Friendship preset in custom night with Shadow Mode enabled and without invincibility.
Melancholy Carronade
Beat Party Cannon preset in custom night with Shadow Mode enabled and without invincibility.
Maud Pie
Beat Cupcakes preset in custom night with Shadow Mode enabled and without invincibility.
Daring Don't
Beat Stranger Than Fan Fiction preset in custom night with Shadow Mode enabled and without invincibility.
Ring of Despair
Beat Stranger Than Fan Fiction 2 preset in custom night with Shadow Mode enabled and without invincibility.
Great Demon King
Beat The Turtle Hermit Way preset in custom night with Shadow Mode enabled and without invincibility.
The Darkest Night Ever
Beat Our Big Night preset in custom night with Shadow Mode enabled and without invincibility.
The Return of Dissonance
Beat Stable 1 preset in custom night with Shadow Mode enabled and without invincibility.
Absolute Discordance
Beat Stable 2 preset in custom night with Shadow Mode enabled and without invincibility.
Limbo
Beat Chaosville preset in custom night with Shadow Mode enabled and without invincibility.
Nightmarish Shadow Play
Beat Nightmare Moon preset in custom night with Shadow Mode enabled and without invincibility.
Sleepless in Ponyville
Beat True Nightmare Moon preset in custom night without invincibility.
Truly Nightmarish Shadow Play
Beat True Nightmare Moon preset in custom night with Shadow Mode enabled and without invincibility.
The Last Problem
Beat Discord's Doomsday preset in custom night without invincibility.
Max Mode Masochist
Beat Discord's Doomsday preset in custom night with Shadow Mode enabled and without invincibility.
The Coda
Collect all six of the Elements of Harmony.