I mean mostly reviews are based more on tastes and things about the product of course but I feel like the hard thing is to say what the game objectively because already this is all kinds of varied and debatable opinions and you don't know for sure what the game is really about

The only thing that if I can recognize objectively is when a game is mediocre and that it could be better, but to recognize a game is good or bad not really.

A creator can say that his own game is bad but everyone likes it and it doesn't even seem like a bad game.

Like A Golden Past 2 for example

I don't get too much into that, I say a game is good when it has good gameplay, mechanics, story and it's fun to play,

But that a game is a masterpiece I think that's something impossible to see, no fnaf fangames is perfect.

Oh and about my previous post I wanted to say that if you get blinded by nostalgia and see that a game has the vibe of a 2015 classic, it doesn't make it a masterpiece, but a good game it can be, I mean there are games like this based on classic fangames that are good like SNaJoe's Remake, I say that because I worry that people misunderstand what I meant.