For context....remember my old post where I debunked my older theory, as I recently found out that Mikey & Mike Jr. we see in DSaF 1 & 2 are all just highly-advanced & hyper-realistic robots, with each set of them being made for each Phone Guy/Scott's clone as a fake children for them to have(each Phone Guy has his own Mikey & his own Mike Jr., with each Mikey also having his own triple set of 3 similarly-made robots, made as his fake friends)?

Remember how I speculated that just like how all Phone Guys are based off the OG, REAL Scott Cawthon, there also may be possibility for all Mikeys & Mike Jr.'s to be based off OG Scott Cawthon's possible real children?

Well.....even more recently I found out that OG Scott has died back in ~1953, with FazBender Ent. spending 20 years to revive him as the first ever "Phone Guy", in ~1973. Phone Guys are all basically cyborgs, made out of human corspes, meaning that Scott couldn't have children anywhere past 1950's(as Phone Guy, he is basically zombie & robot at the same time, & neither zombies or robots can biologically reproduce).

And cuz of that, by 1983, these assumed kids must be at least around ±30 years old, which means FNaF 4 CC/Mike Jr.(the bite victim at FredBear's), & by extension, his older brother Mikey/FoxyBro, CAN'T be these children in question, & are just another set of robots

But then I wondered....

Wait a sec....ya know who COULD be his possible children?

JACK & PETER KENNEDY!

And here's the evidence:

1. Peter was born in August of 1945, while Jack was born in March of 1951, meaning they both were born BEFORE Scott's most estimated death, & by 1953, Peter would be ±8 years old, while Jack would be ±2 years old. This may imply at least a possibility of them being his kids

   • Jack's birth month is March, & Mike Jr.'s "birth month" is May, which ik are 2 completely different months but.....hey, they are both Spring months, they are relatively close to each other, & on top of that, the words "March" & "May" sounds & spelled similar, with them both starting with "Ma". So maybe Abel just misremembered Scott's youngest son to be born in May instead of March when he was making the first Mike Jr.(after all, he didn't saw those kids around for the past 20 years, how would he remember?)

2. In DSaF 2, Jack posts a theory on Freddit where he assumes that FNaF lore is all just a dream of a walrus. Coincidentally, in DSaF 3, Harry tells about "Reginald the Flying Walrus"—a character that the kids of the FazBender Ent. managers(which could include Jack & Peter as well, if we assume they are Scott's children) had collectively came up with & suggested to be the final 4th member of Freddy's band.

   • I doubt it was Jack himself who came up with Reginald ofc, as he was too young by that point, but....hey, maybe it was Peter's idea originally, & Jack just liked it so much that he started loving walruses :3

   • Also, in DSaF 2 Jack says on Freddit that "his uncle worked for Scott Cawthon", which may be him misremembering being a son of Scott himself(after all, we know Jack has a horrible problem with memory loss. He even forgets his own name in DSaF 3, thinking for a sec that his real name is "Jeremy Fritzgerald".)

3. If you look at Peter's haircut before "Phone-Heading" process, it kinda looks the same as Mikey's haircut. On top of that, Jack's skin color before becoming "Orange Guy" relatively matches with Mike Jr's skin tone

   • In fact, I even would say that Peter's skin color kinda matches FNaF: SL Michael Afton's skin color, which again makes a link between him, Mikey & Mike Jr. The same goes for Jack's blue eye color, which matches with eyes of both Michael from SL AND Mike Schmidt from FNaF 1(who we know are both just Jack under alias in DSaF universe).

   • Also, if we assume that Mikey's hair could be based of Scott's oldest son's hair, then maybe Mike Jr.'s haircut could be based off what Abel assumed Scott's youngest son's hair would be(he didn't knew that Jack would end up having alapecia).

4. Both Jack & Mikey are heavily connected to Foxy, with him being their fav Freddy's character. Mikey goes around in Foxy mask, & Jack.....well, ya know 💀

   • Also, both Mikey & Jack are quite of a jerks, with them being pretty mean to most of people around them, & also have a weird sense of humour

5. Both Jack & Mike Jr. are heavily connected to yellow Freddy look-a-likes, with FredBear being Mike Jr's fav mascot(plushie of which is also his imaginary best friend & fav plushie), & Golden Freddy/SpringFreddy springlock suits being Jack's costumes to wear most of the time.

   • Also, FredBear is the one who bit off Mike Jr.'s frontal lob on his birthday, while SpringFreddy costume is the one who shreds Jack's frontal lob in DSaF 2 "Golden Bear Scr#tum" ending.

6. Both Jack & Mike Jr. had canonically lost their frontal lobs at least once, with Mike getting bitten by FredBear in FNaF 4 mini-games, & Jack getting bitten by either SpringFreddy(Golden Bear Scr#tum Ending) or Nightmare Foxy(Forgotten Ending) in DSaF 2.

   • Their incidents are also named similarly—"The Bite of '83" for Mike Jr., & "The Bite of '87" for Jack. These incidents also both were horrific enough for their respective restaurants(FredBear's Family Diner/#0 in Mike Jr's case, & Freddy FazBender's Pepperonerie/#51 in Jack's case) to get closed down, with both cases being almost equally painful for the FazBender Ent. company.

   • 

     On top of that, both Jack(both endings) & Mike Jr. fell in coma & got hospitalized after that, with Jack's coma in DSaF 2 "Forgotten Ending" cutscene being a literal replica of FNaF 4 Night 6 cutscene. They even both feature them talking with a plushies of those who bit them—in Mike Jr's case it is FredBear, & in Jack's case it is Foxy(in bikini....yeah, don't question that 💀)

     

7. Jack's house in DSaF 2 is literally FNaF 4 bedroom & FNaF: SL living room, again, making his connection with Mikes stronger

8. Jack in general is literally DSaF version of Michael Afton, don't think that needs to be elaborated on. Jack even steals Michael's role of FNaF: SL & FNaF 1 protagonist, being both the nightguard who worked at the first Freddy FazBender's Pepperonerie Pizza in November of 1993, as seen in PSTK, & also the nightguard/technician of FAZBUNKER, who got scooped & then used as a skin-suit by Ennard.

   • 

     In fact, back in the DSaF 2 in-development days, according to the wiki, Jack's real name was supposed to be "Michael Schmidt", not "Jack Kennedy", & considering that FNaF 1 Mike Schmidt had already used to be theorized to be one of FNaF 4 brothers, it is possible that a plot twist like that could be possible in DSaF as well(hell, imagine an alt. universe, where instead of reveal that DSaF 2 Phone Guy is our player character's brother, it would be instead revealed that our player character is actually Phone Guy's son🙃)

   • Along with that, despite, its pretty possible that the name "Old Sport" on Night 5 paycheck in PSTK is not literally a nickname that Jack used to apply for his job, but instead just Dave writting it there as a joke, showing that he recognized him. So its not out of possibility that Jack's real fake name that time is actually "Mike Schmidt", just like in OG FNaF 1.(heck, if we assume FNaF: SL having "MIKE" sticker on HandUnit is also canon to DSaF, then maybe he even used this nickname to apply to FAZBUNKER)

   • Heck, the entire Kennedy family are basically just DSaF version of Afton family from OG FNaF, with them also having an older brother, a younger brother, & a sister(Dee being the youngest of Kennedy siblings even may be a reference to Elizabeth being usually theorized as the youngest of Afton siblings).

   • Also, Jack having parallels with both Mikey/FoxyBro AND Mike Jr./Crying Child may be an even bigger nod to the whole "MikeBully VS MikeVictim" debate, & how people back in the day couldn't agree on if Michael Afton is FoxyBro OR CC. The same also goes for Peter.

So in conclusion, we have THIS possible story:

At first, around mid-1940's, we had Scott Cawthon himself, who had married a woman who, in 1945, then gave birth to his first son, who they then named "Michael Bono Cawthon". Then, 6 years later, in 1951, she gave birth to a second son, who they, due to lack of creativity, had just named "Michael Bono Cawthon Jr.", with the first one getting renamed into "Michael Bono Cawthon Sr.". To differ between them two, they call the younger one as "Mike Jr.", or just "Mike", & the older one as "Mike Sr.", or just "Mikey"

Then, probably due to some argument between them, Scott has divorced his wife, & she moved away with both of their children to Reno, Nevada, along with taking the whole custody of them. She also changed her last name from "Cawthon" to "Schmidt"(which I assume is her née last name), & also did the same with the kids, renaming them into "Michael Bono Schmidt Sr." & "Michael Bono Schmidt Jr."(although it is also not out of possibility that Scott & {Mrs. Cawthon Schmidt} had never divorced, & she did all of that already AFTER Scott died).

Then, at some point, let's say 1965, she finds a new husband for herself, whose last name is "Kennedy". And I suppose only after THAT she realized how lame & confusing it is to have 2 sons with identical names(or maybe it just took too long for their new stepfather to stop confusing them), so they decided to not just name them "Michael Bono Kennedy Sr." & "Michael Bono Kennedy Jr.", but instead finally give them both their individual names. I even would assume that due to lack of creativity, they probably let the kids choose their new names themselves.

The names in question were "Peter Thomas Kennedy", for older brother, & "Jack Fitzgerald Kennedy", for younger brother. I even would assume that Mike Jr./Jack could named himself like that....just cuz he couldn't name himself "John Fitzgerald Kennedy"(either his parents or his brother could have stopped him), yet still wanted to make his new name be an elaborate JFK joke XD

A few years later, on June 23rd, 1967, {Mr. Kennedy} & {Mrs. Schmidt Kennedy} had gave birth to another, third child in their family—a girl who was named "Dee Kennedy". And everything could be great....if not the fact that both {Mr. Kennedy} AND {Mrs. Schmidt Kennedy} were a horrible human beings(I even assume that a possible divorce between Scott & his {Mrs. Cawthon Schmidt Kennedy} could have happened due to her being a total b#tch & sl#t), who didn't even wanted to have kids that much. As a result, one day they just abandoned all 3 of their children by driving away from home & then just purposefully trying to make themselves get into a car crash(yes, you read it right, they decided they would rather commit suicide than take of their kids 😭💀), leaving Peter, Jack & Dee all alone, trying to survive on their own.

What happened later? Well, if ya played DSaF, you know the rest of the story: Peter had eventually married his new wife—Caroline, moved away from Reno, Nevada to Denver, Colorado, leaving Jack taking all of the care about Dee, then Jack gets a job as a nightguard at FredBear's Family Diner, yada-yada.

The only what should be noted is that somewhere around ±1973, Abel Brannigan & other 4 OG FazBender Ent. managers had finally revived Scott, turning him into what we now know as "the first Phone Guy". And then, to make him seem more alive, they also tried to recreate his entire family, or specifically, his children. As it was 20 years since anyone of them had seen his actual sons, these 2 new robots they made to replace them were mostly based of what they remembered of them, or rather, what they imagined they both would be after they would grew up a lil' bit:

1. For example, THE REAL Mike Sr.'s/Peter's possible "jokester" personality that he had back when he was 8(but which then has been toning down over time until he would become what he is now—a mature & serious young man) was not just given to new "Mikey/Mike Sr." robot, but was also would be extremely exaggerated, making him an outright mean-spirited & rebelious teenager who loves bullying everyone.

   • They also thought that it would be cooler to give him friends, and thats why "Freddy Bully" robot, "Bonnie Bully" robot, & "Chica Bully" robot now exist, being programmed to be the same stereotypical school bullies like him.

2. "Mike Jr." robot's case is even funnier. As the real Mike Jr./Jack was literally 2 years old the last time they saw him, they instead just decided to make his personality be a complete exaggerated opposite & foil of "Mikey" robot—a constantly terrified coward & crybaby, which as you can guess is also a total opposite of what Jack actually grew up to be over the years—a charismatic jerk with love for black humour, making "Mikey" being more similar to HIM, then to Peter.

They also didn't knew that the names of their real prototypes were changed, so they just used the same names "Michael Bono Schmidt Sr." & "Michael Bono Schmidt Jr." that their mother was using for them before meeting their stepdad.

Funnily enough though, they never made a robot replica of {Mr. Cawthon Schmidt Kennedy} herself, instead just programming the whole "you & your wife had divorced & she took the kids away, thats why their last name is different from yours & why you'll never meet them anywhere outside this place" into "Scott" robot's/OG Phone Guy's AI, & giving him a fake photo of his new fake family.

And thus, the Cawthon family was artificially rebuild, & now is mass-produced to every Freddy's location. BOOM

Also, just a side note: if we consider this theory to be true, then this even explains how FNaC, which also seems to be canon to DSaF, fits into the story. Like what if {Mrs. Cawthon Schmidt Kennedy} actually had a secret brother? And that brother in question would be none other than a father of Mary Schmidt from FNaC 1 & 3, making Mary & Jack basically cousins :3

Anyway, thats it for today. Have a great evening fellas! Sayanora, old sports! ^w^

And REMEMBER! THATS Just a Theory! A GAAAAAME THEORY! Thanks for reading! >:3