Game is fantastic and still one of the scariest and most interesting ones. You dont need fully re-invent FNAF mechanics or lore, its all depends on your approach. It was our first serious game and you want from that game be at the level of TJOC or actual FNAF games by Scott? Well, sorry, its way too much for a free game where we are not even paid for.
Games are meant to be made for fun when it comes to FAN making, no competition, no extra effort to risk make it all crumble. Wathel meant to be a parody to Cave, that what makes it fun. Whole game is just FNAF 1 being reimagined in some way and its just alright, we never aimed too high - its our first game. Something cool will arrive later with original IP. We made the game to learn, we did. We released it, while many others failed. I think it's already a fantastic acchievement.